I found the worst case for headlights wasn't when it was very dark, as on a trail, but rather when it was dark and cars were approaching from the opposite direction. For a totally dark ride, my Blackburn Quadrant and $30 Cateye were fine, but if I didn't want oncoming headlights to blind me, I had to add a Niterider MiNewt Mini-USB.
My MiNewt is also one of the older two-piece models. It's good, much brighter than the others, but the mount for the lamp on mine lets it slowly change directions, just a bit each time you hit a bump. And the light doesn't spread much, and isn't visible from the sides, so I only use it along with my Quadrant, which flashes to the sides too.